Pilgrims need a pilgrim hat or bonnet and a large collar. Wampanoag puppets can be decked out with a feather atop the head and some fringe somewhere. Some puppets are holding corn, a cornucopia or a turkey leg for extra humor.
Afterwards, the kiddos can use these as puppets to create their own Thanksgiving stories. You can bring a Mayflower and a turkey puppet, and maybe an ear of corn puppet to add to the play props.
These did take a lot of work, but you could also find a Pilgrim and Wampanoag clipart figure and just paste on people's faces. I love how these turned out...here are two of my favorites...